Jake | Thursday 7th June 2012 | Superbikes

Isle of Man TT - 2011

ITV4 has been covering the Isle of Man TT for a good few years now, and a grand old job it’s done. Indeed, I said the channel deserved a medal in 2009. But little has changed since then, so it’s about time for some mild criticism.

Time for more timing

The coverage has always done – and continues to do – a fantastic job of conveying the madness of racing motorbikes around the island’s roads at frightening speeds, averaging up to 130mph or so. But it’s never really got to grips with how to tell the story of the races.

With the TT races being time trials, and riders setting off individually at intervals, it’s tough to convey who’s fighting who for position on adjusted time. But rallying manages, doesn’t it?

We just need more timing data on screen. All we get at the moment is a frustratingly brief look at the top six at the end of each lap, and very occasional split times. It’s got to the point now that it’s even hobbling the commentators, who at times can’t even say who’s leading the race due to a lack of data.

It might be more fundamental than that, though: the highlights need to be built a little more around the race, rather than showing off fancy camera work. That way more timing data should almost come naturally.

Not that I want less fancy camera work, just for it to be used a bit more as a means to tell the story of the race, and not as an end in itself.

Less slow motion, more on-board

After all, the stunning footage is what makes the coverage so enjoyable.

It was the first place I remember seeing high motion cameras being used to produce the astonishing slow motion shots that we now see in a lot of motorsport coverage. I wouldn’t want to lose those great slow motion shots, but it’s no longer special enough to virtually build the coverage around.

What is special about the TT is riders speeding past walls and hedges at staggeringly close proximity. On-board cameras convey that better than anything, so that’s I’d like to see more of. The technology is getting better and smaller too, so there are loads of options – gyro cams, helmet cams, and more places on the bike to put cameras.

What has improved

I don’t want to be negative though. There have been improvements over the years: what was initially a curious commentary combination in Steve Parrish and James Whitham, for example, is now completely natural.

And this year’s coverage is still essential viewing. It’s just that it could be even better.

Photo Credit
Automotive Rhythms – FlickrSome rights reserved

There are 2 comments

  1. Comment by J, Saturday 9th June 2012 @ 11:23

    Hi, Jake is it, I enjoy your blog very much – post more articles!

    I agree with you but it must be hard to put together highlights for such an event.

    There’s nothing like siting by the side of the track and listening live on the radio. This is where I think they could learn, they should provide the updates each lap as they do on the radio, Glen Helen, Ramsey Hairpin, Grandstand. They could then talk about the changes of position, who is making a move, etc, and then just let the pictures talk for themselves.

    I think someone who understands the TT is maybe missing from the editing team, for example last night they had Cam Donald talk through on board of a lap, this was edited, which I think they should have shown all the lap, it’s less than 20 mins. Additionally it was edited very badly, e.g. They cut away from th footage just as he came through the bottom of Bray Hill, and missed out a lot of the good bits.

    Just out of interest have you ever had the chance to come over to our fair isle for the TT?

  2. Comment by Jake, Saturday 9th June 2012 @ 14:18

    Hi J, thanks for your kind words!

    Yeah, it can’t be easy to put the highlights together, and they do a good job. You could be right about the edit team missing someone who understands the TT. It’s like the Dakar – the edit always produced great pictures, but not the story of the race – but that started to change, and definitely for the better.

    Like your idea of a full on board lap. Like that a lot! There has to be a place for that in either the preview or review shows, if not during race week.

    I’ve not been over to the TT, but it’s something I’d love to do one of these days.

Post a comment

Twitter
    Follow 2or4 on Twitter